Do You Have to Use Your Insurer’s Preferred Body Shop?

No. You are not required to use the body shop your insurance company recommends. In the United States, you have the right to choose who repairs your vehicle, and an insurer cannot legally force you into a specific shop. They can suggest a “preferred” or “direct repair” shop, and there are real conveniences to using one, but the final choice is yours. Here is what that means in practice for drivers in South Dakota.

Where the “preferred shop” idea comes from

Most insurers maintain a network of shops they call “direct repair program” (DRP) or “preferred” shops. These shops have an agreement with the insurer: they offer pre-negotiated pricing and streamlined paperwork in exchange for a steady flow of referred customers. When you file a claim, the adjuster will often steer you toward one of these shops because it is faster and cheaper for the insurance company.

That arrangement can be convenient. But it is built around the insurer’s interests as much as yours, and the referral is a suggestion — not a requirement.

Your right to choose

You are free to take your vehicle to any licensed shop you trust. The insurer still pays for the covered repairs based on an agreed estimate, regardless of which shop does the work. An adjuster who implies you “have to” use their shop, or that your claim will be denied otherwise, is overstepping. What they can do is cap what they will pay at a reasonable market rate for the repair; a reputable independent shop works within that just as a network shop does.

The trade-offs of each choice

Using the insurer’s preferred shop can mean less paperwork, a faster start, and sometimes a repair warranty backed by the insurer. The downside is that the shop’s agreement is with the insurer, which can create pressure to keep costs down — for example, by favoring used or aftermarket parts over original-equipment (OEM) parts, or by moving quickly.

Choosing your own shop lets you pick a repairer based on reputation, workmanship, and how they treat your vehicle — not on who has the cheapest contract. A good independent shop advocates for a complete, correct repair and will deal with your insurer on your behalf. If you already know and trust a local shop, that relationship is worth a lot when your vehicle’s safety is on the line.

What to watch for

  • Parts: ask whether your repair uses OEM or aftermarket parts, and what your policy entitles you to. This matters for fit, safety systems, and resale value — a point that comes up often in quality collision repair.
  • The estimate: a low initial estimate can mean hidden damage gets missed. A thorough shop does a full teardown inspection and submits a supplement if it finds more.
  • Warranty: ask who stands behind the work and for how long.
  • Pressure: if anyone tells you that you must use a particular shop, remember that the choice is legally yours.

How the process works when you choose your own shop

It is simpler than people expect. You tell your insurer which shop you have chosen. The shop inspects the vehicle, writes a detailed estimate, and works directly with your adjuster to agree on the scope and cost — including any supplements for hidden damage found during the repair. You generally pay only your deductible. A shop that handles insurance work routinely will manage most of this for you, so you are not stuck playing middleman.

Frequently asked questions

Can my insurance company deny my claim if I don’t use their shop?

No. Choosing your own licensed shop is your right and is not grounds to deny a valid claim. The insurer still pays for covered repairs at a reasonable rate wherever the work is done.

Will it cost me more to use my own shop?

Not usually. The insurer pays the agreed amount for the repair regardless of shop. If a shop charges above the market rate the insurer approves, you would owe the difference — which is why a clear, agreed estimate upfront matters.

Do preferred shops do worse work?

Not necessarily — many are excellent. The point is that the choice should be based on the shop’s quality and your trust, not on pressure from an adjuster.

What if hidden damage is found after the estimate?

A good shop documents it and submits a supplement to your insurer for approval before completing the repair, so the car is fixed properly rather than to the first guess.

Related reading: learn how to read your repair estimate, and what it means if the insurer declares your car a total loss.

Choose a shop you trust in Sioux Falls

At Boxy’s Paint & Body in Sioux Falls, we work with every major insurer and handle the back-and-forth for you — while making sure your vehicle gets the complete, correct repair it needs. The choice of shop is always yours. Call (605) 543-5568 or schedule a repair to get started.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Skip to content